It is reasonable to say that around 1998, among Japanese metal fans, IN FLAMES was rapidly elevated from “a new band known only to a handful of fanatics” to a promising act poised to play a central role in melodic death metal. Particularly during the WHORACLE period, they were valued as a band that connected the lyricism of IRON MAIDEN-style twin guitars with the aggression of death metal, and were expected to lead the HM/HR scene in the future. However, the center of this evaluation was still specialist magazines and dedicated fans; it had not yet expanded to nationwide recognition or widespread popularity among metal listeners.
PERIOD CONTEXT
From the Japanese perspective at the time, IN FLAMES’s appeal was not simply “fast and aggressive death metal,” but guitar melodies with a strong sense of song. During the transition from THE JESTER RACE to WHORACLE, they were discussed as a band that retained its lyricism while making its sound tighter and increasing its aggression. In other words, they had the potential to reach not only underground death metal enthusiasts, but also listeners who favored traditional HM or IRON MAIDEN-style guitar melodies. In the introduction to WHORACLE at the end of 1997, expectations for the advance tracks included both the reassuring sense of continuity with the earlier records and an even greater heaviness, with particular hopes for dramatic songs comparable to “Stand Ablaze” and “Moonshield.” This indicates that the earlier records had already become strong reference points among readers of Japanese specialist magazines. At the first Japanese shows in spring 1998, their musicianship, stagecraft, and the audience’s excitement were highly praised. At the same time, the live side was also seen as having room for improvement compared with the finished quality of the studio recordings. This was less a negative evaluation than the reverse side of the expectation that “the records are already first-rate, and the band will become huge if it grows as a live act.” Thus, in Japan at the time, IN FLAMES was positioned not as an established major act, but as a young band “on the verge of a breakthrough,” ready to push melodic death in a new direction.
LISTEN NEXT
EVIDENCE
- BURRN! 1997年11月号Expectations for the new record’s lyricism and heavinessPraise for dramatic songs on the level of “Moonshield”
- BURRN! 1998年5月号・Discussion of musicianship, future potential, and the live side
- BURRN! 2022年5月号・The historical position of the early records as seen from a later period
CONFIDENCE
High
NOTES
This is not an estimate based on an opinion poll covering Japanese fans as a whole or a comparison of sales scale, but an assessment inferred from criticism in specialist magazines and reactions to Japanese shows. Therefore, the views of dedicated HM/HR readers can be traced, but the level of recognition among casual listeners cannot be asserted with the same degree of precision.